Summary of the Film Review: “The Incomer“
This review describes “The Incomer” as a peculiar and challenging film from Scottish writer-director Louis Paxton. Here’s a breakdown of the key points:
* Plot: The film centers around Isla and Sandy, siblings who have lived in isolation on a remote island since their parents’ death. Their unusual, almost childlike existence is disrupted by Daniel, a local councilor sent to evict them.
* Tone & Style: The film is characterized by its “debauched fairytales,” quirky humor,and deliberately askew angle. It blends absurdity with moments of sincerity,and utilizes animated sequences to tell the island’s myths. The reviewer finds the tone often alienating and “twee.”
* Characters:
* Isla & Sandy: Portrayed as brutish, stunted, and more like children than adults. Their isolation has left them on the border of reality and myth.
* Daniel: Played by Domhnall Gleeson, he’s a milquetoast middle manager who uses technology (“wizard powers”) to gain the siblings’ trust. He develops sympathy for them.
* Themes: The film touches on themes of isolation, trauma, abandonment, the disconnect of modern life, and the clash between rural and urban existence. It attempts to highlight the absurdity of modern conveniences by contrasting them with the siblings’ ignorance.
* Criticisms: The reviewer finds the film repetitive in its jokes about the siblings’ ignorance, and feels the sincere moments are often jarringly inserted.The climax veers into cliché (“revenge of the nerds”) territory.
* Positive Aspects: Gleeson’s performance is praised, as is Grant O’Rourke’s portrayal of sandy. The cinematography is occasionally beautiful. The reviewer acknowledges that the film’s unique style resonated with some viewers.
* Overall Impression: The reviewer ultimately found the film frustrating and off-putting, but recognizes that its blend of absurdity and sentimentality might appeal to others. It’s a film that elicits a strong reaction, even if it’s not a universally positive one.
In essence, the review paints “The Incomer” as a highly unconventional film that demands patience and a willingness to embrace its oddities. It’s a film that will likely divide audiences.
Keep reading