Are the Lakers, Knicks and others true contenders? What 7 metrics over 20 years tell us The Los Angeles Lakers and New York Knicks have shown signs of improvement in the 2025-26 NBA season, with both teams sitting above .500 and positioning themselves for playoff contention. As the regular season nears its conclusion, evaluating their legitimacy as true contenders requires looking beyond win-loss records to deeper performance indicators. Over the past two decades, seven key metrics have consistently separated playoff pretenders from legitimate championship threats. Applying these benchmarks to the current Lakers and Knicks rosters reveals where each team stands—and what they must improve to be taken seriously as title contenders. Defensive consistency remains the most reliable predictor of postseason success. Since 2004, teams that finish in the top 10 in defensive rating have won 80% of NBA championships. The Lakers currently rank 12th in defensive rating (112.0 points allowed per 100 possessions), while the Knicks check in at 8th (109.5). New York’s defensive foundation, built around Mitchell Robinson’s rim protection and O.G. Anunoby’s perimeter versatility, gives them a clear edge in this category. Los Angeles, despite improved effort in recent games, still struggles with defensive communication and transition defense, particularly when Luka Dončić is off the ball. Offensive efficiency is equally critical. Teams in the top 5 in offensive rating have reached the NBA Finals in 70% of seasons over the last 20 years. The Lakers rank 6th in offensive rating (115.8), driven by Dončić’s playmaking and Austin Reaves’ scoring bursts. The Knicks, meanwhile, sit at 14th (111.2), relying heavily on Julius Randle’s isolation scoring and Jalen Brunson’s mid-range game. While New York’s offense is functional, it lacks the elite shot creation and spacing seen in true title teams. Rebounding margin often goes overlooked but correlates strongly with playoff longevity. Since 2004, teams with a positive rebounding margin of at least 3.0 per game have won 65% of playoff series when facing opponents with negative margins. The Lakers currently hold a +4.1 rebounding margin, bolstered by Domantas Sabonis’ emergence as a dual-threat large and Christian Wood’s energy off the bench. The Knicks, despite Robinson’s presence, are only +1.8, as their guards struggle to crash the boards consistently. Turnover differential reveals a team’s ability to protect the ball and create extra possessions. Championship-caliber teams typically maintain a turnover margin of at least +2.0. The Lakers are at +1.7, improved from earlier in the season but still vulnerable in high-pressure moments. The Knicks check in at +0.9, a concern given Brunson’s high usage rate and the team’s reliance on pick-and-roll actions that can lead to steals. Clutch performance—defined as games within five points in the final five minutes—separates good teams from great ones. Over the last 20 years, teams with a clutch winning percentage above .600 have won 75% of championships. The Lakers are 18-12 (.600) in clutch situations this season, a direct result of Dončić’s late-game poise and Reaves’ timely shooting. The Knicks, yet, are just 14-16 (.467), often settling for contested jumpers instead of attacking the paint or finding open shooters. Star power impact remains non-negotiable. Since 2004, every NBA champion has had at least one player ranked in the top 10 in Player Impact Estimate (PIE). Luka Dončić currently ranks 4th in league PIE (18.7), while Julius Randle is 22nd (12.1) and Brunson 15th (14.3). New York lacks a true elite-tier performer, whereas Los Angeles possesses a perennial All-NBA candidate in Dončić, elevating their ceiling significantly. Finally, health and availability predict postseason durability. Teams that lose fewer than 250 man-games to injury have won 85% of titles since 2004. The Lakers have lost 218 man-games this season, largely due to Dončić’s groin strain and Anthony Davis’ recurring calf issues. The Knicks have lost 194 man-games, a more manageable figure, but Randle’s ankle sprain and Brunson’s knee tendinitis have limited their consistency. Based on these seven metrics, the Lakers currently meet or exceed championship benchmarks in offensive rating, rebounding margin, clutch performance, and star impact—falling slightly short only in defensive consistency and turnover control. The Knicks excel defensively and in health management but lag in offensive efficiency, clutch execution, and star power. For either team to be considered a true contender, they must address their weakest areas: Los Angeles needs to tighten its defensive rotations, while New York must develop a more reliable go-to scorer and improve late-game decision-making. Until then, both remain dangerous playoff teams—but not yet the franchises to beat.
28