“Cold War Choir Practice” at MCC Theater: A Review

Ro Reddick’s Cold War Choir Practice, currently playing at MCC Theater, initially presents a lighthearted comedy about a Black family in 1987 Syracuse, New York, but evolves into a more complex, and ultimately uneven, exploration of Cold War anxieties and political tensions. While boasting a stellar cast led by Alana Raquel Bowers, the play struggles to reconcile its insightful character work with an over-the-top espionage plot.

A Family Amidst Fear

The play centers on Meek (Alana Raquel Bowers), convincingly portrayed as a ten-year-old, who lives with her father, Smooch (Will Cobbs), and grandmother, Puddin (Lizan Mitchell), in a struggling roller rink. As Christmas approaches, Meek grapples with fears of nuclear war, fueled by her involvement in the Seedlings of Peace Children’s Choir, where the choir leader (Ellen Winter) discusses the threat of Soviet nuclear weapons. Meek believes that “the voice of a child can stop a nuclear attack” and prepares the choir to sing songs of peace, hoping to avert disaster before an intercontinental ballistic missile can reach the U.S.

Music and Political Undercurrents

Reddick’s original musical numbers, performed by a three-member adult choir featuring Grace McLean, Suzzy Roche, and Nina Ross, add a delightful layer to the production. Songs like “Milkshake for Peace,” satirize the era’s attempts at cultural diplomacy. The play as well deftly explores the political complexities of being Black in America during the 1980s. Smooch, a former Black Panther, purchased the skating rink to revitalize a community fixture, while his brother, Clay (Andy Lucien), now works for the Reagan administration, creating familial tension.

A Tangled Espionage Plot

However, the play veers into less convincing territory with the introduction of an espionage plot. Clay, as Deputy National Security Advisor, possesses crucial documents related to nuclear treaties. Meek becomes entangled in a scheme involving a Soviet pen pal and a cult-like organization, Wellspring (inspired by the 1980s group Lifespring), both vying to obtain these documents. This shift towards a “Mission: Impossible” style narrative undermines the play’s earlier insights and feels contrived.

Historical Context and Reflections

Reddick, in an author’s note, connects the play’s themes to contemporary geopolitical concerns, including the war in Ukraine. However, the play’s cartoonish portrayal of espionage risks oversimplifying the complexities of both the Cold War and current events. Despite this, the production succeeds in capturing the atmosphere of the 1980s through details like the use of a Speak & Spell and Atomic Fireballs candy.

Cast and Production Details

In addition to Bowers, Cobbs, and Mitchell, the cast includes Crystal Finn as Virgie. The creative team features direction by Knud Adams, music direction by Ellen Winter, set design by Afsoon Pajoufar, costume design by Brenda Abbandandolo, lighting design by Masha Tsimring, and movement direction by Baye & Asa.

Cold War Choir Practice runs at MCC Theater through March 29, 2026.