Ruyterwacht Residents Divided Over Alleged Brothel on Elizabeth Street

Tensions are rising in Ruyterwacht, Cape Town, as residents voice concerns over an alleged brothel operating on Elizabeth Street. The situation has sparked disagreement between neighbors, with some claiming illegal activity and others dismissing the accusations as unfounded.

Resident’s Concerns

One resident, who wished to remain anonymous, expressed regret over moving to the area due to what she believes is a problem property. She alleges the property is being used as a brothel, stating, “Apparently there are two other brothels in the area, but I am only aware of this one, which is illegal.”

The resident detailed observing frequent activity at the property, including constant traffic of people entering and exiting for short periods. She claims to have researched the property and discovered it is advertised as a guesthouse but is, in her opinion, operating as a brothel. She specifically noted increased activity on weekends and expressed concern for the children in the neighborhood, stating, “We need this place to be shut down because there are children and they cannot be exposed to this.”

The resident further alleges the property is run by foreigners who are not the owners and contribute to disturbances with noise from cars and late-night activity.

Tenants Deny Allegations

Tenants at the property refuted the claims, dismissing them as stemming from a personal issue with a neighbor. They stated they are aware of the accusations but maintain their innocence. “We are aware that they think we are running a sex house, but it is not true. There is one neighbour who has a problem with us,” one tenant said.

The tenants explained they are residents renting rooms, with some working and others attending school. They asserted that visitors are family and friends and spot no issue with their presence. They also mentioned previous investigations by municipal authorities that found no evidence to support the allegations.

City Investigating the Matter

Ward Councillor Christopher Jordaan confirmed he received a complaint regarding the alleged brothel on Tuesday and forwarded it to the relevant department for investigation. He plans to send out Environmental and Building Inspectors to verify the claims and issue a notice if necessary.

Alderman Eddie Andrews, the City’s Deputy Mayor and Mayoral Committee Member for Spatial Planning and Environment, stated that a 30-day compliance notice was issued to the property owner and tenants on February 9, 2026, regarding an unauthorized guesthouse. Daily Voice reports the City is aware of the situation and the Land Use Enforcement team is addressing the matter.

The City of Cape Town’s Law Enforcement Department will also conduct an on-site visit to investigate the allegations, according to Wayne Dyason, the City’s Law Enforcement Spokesperson.

Recent Community Concerns in Ruyterwacht

This situation follows other recent community concerns in Ruyterwacht, including opposition to the demolition of the Life Changing Ministries church to make way for a block of flats. Daily Voice reported on this dispute in October 2023, with residents citing the church’s cultural and religious significance.