Motor Assess Ireland Seeks to Restrain Salvage Business Over Vehicle Access Dispute
The High Court is hearing a case brought by Motor Assess Ireland (MAI) Ltd against SDSI Ltd, concerning access to vehicles for inspection. MAI, a motor inspection and salvage management firm working on behalf of insurers, alleges that SDSI, a salvage storage provider, is unlawfully preventing access to vehicles at its facilities.
Background of the Dispute
MAI, which operates a network of over 40 engineers nationwide, previously contracted SDSI for salvage and storage services at its “end-of-life vehicle” facilities. The relationship deteriorated following a dispute over increases in salvage management fees. In December 2024, SDSI indicated its intention to withdraw services, but the contract continued on increased terms until March 2025, when MAI engaged a latest sub-contractor. Western People reports that in April 2025, Allianz Insurance directly contracted with SDSI for salvage management, replacing MAI.
Allegations of Unlawful Interference
According to an affidavit from Aisling Deasy, MAI’s chief operating officer, since December 2025, SDSI has denied MAI engineers access to vehicles at several of its facilities. This action, MAI argues, constitutes unlawful interference with its business and contractual relations. The dispute also involves a claim by SDSI for money allegedly owed by MAI, a claim that MAI denies.
Court Proceedings
On Friday, March 6, 2026, Justice Brian Cregan granted permission for short service of the proceedings on SDSI, representing MAI in court. The case has been adjourned to next week. The Irish Times and The Echo both reported on the initial court hearing.
Key Takeaways
- MAI is seeking a court order to compel SDSI to allow access to vehicles for inspection.
- The dispute stems from a breakdown in their commercial relationship following disagreements over fees.
- SDSI is also claiming money is owed by MAI, a claim MAI disputes.
- The High Court has granted MAI permission to expedite the legal proceedings.