Waterford Students Face Consequences After Damaging Rental Property

Waterford, Ireland – A group of students celebrating the conclude of their freshman year (“freshers’ celebrations”) caused significant damage to a rental property in Tramore, County Waterford, resulting in a court case and a €3,000 bill for repairs. The incident highlights the potential liabilities associated with short-term rentals and the importance of responsible behavior during student events.

Details of the Incident

Ameer Zakaria Prendergast (20), of Kilkenny, rented a house just outside Tramore via Booking.com for himself and four friends. According to evidence presented in Waterford Courthouse on March 2, 2026, a large party took place at the property on the final night of their stay, leading to extensive damage estimated at €3,000. Prendergast was charged under Section 2(1) of the Criminal Damage Act.

Court Proceedings and Outcome

Judge Kevin Staunton heard the case and noted the “significant damage” to the property, characterizing the event as a “very wild party.” Prendergast, who has no prior convictions, quickly admitted to the damages and attempted to resolve the issue directly with Booking.com. He subsequently took responsibility by paying the full €3,000 to the property owner.

His solicitor informed the court that Prendergast felt “let down” by his friends, who did not contribute to the cost of the repairs. Judge Staunton commented that Prendergast had been “left carry the can” while his friends “rode off into the sunset,” and expressed hope that the experience would serve as a “life lesson” regarding trust.

the matter was struck out, meaning no formal conviction was recorded against Prendergast.

Previous Cases Involving Judge Kevin Staunton

Judge Kevin Staunton has presided over a number of cases in Waterford District Court, including a February 18, 2025, case where he refused to impose a conviction on a man for carrying goods on an e-scooter, deeming a conviction “unfair” despite the State proving its case [Irish Times]. He also presided over a case on July 14, 2025, involving a man fined €300 for public intoxication after being given an initial opportunity to return home [Waterford News].

Implications for Rental Property Owners and Students

This case serves as a cautionary tale for both rental property owners and students. Owners should carefully vet renters, particularly those booking through short-term rental platforms, and consider requiring security deposits to cover potential damages. Students should be aware of their responsibilities as tenants and the potential legal and financial consequences of damaging property.