A £880m Gamble to Save the High Street
Andy Burnham has unveiled a radical plan to overhaul business rates, a move estimated to cost approximately £880m annually. The proposal seeks to expand Small Business Rates Relief by lifting thresholds for rateable values, bankrolled by a fresh tax offensive against the large-scale warehouse developments that anchor the e-commerce sector.
Targeting Logistics to Subsidize Main Street
Burnham contends the current tax architecture unfairly punishes brick-and-mortar storefronts while rolling out the red carpet for logistics giants. His strategy is simple: hike rates on massive, out-of-town distribution centers to provide a fiscal lifeline for the pubs, cafés, restaurants, and hairdressers struggling to keep their lights on.
Burnham has publicly stated that the government should prioritize businesses that provide “social benefit.” Under his plan, the threshold for full Small Business Rates Relief would climb from a rateable value of £12,000 to £18,000. He also proposes pushing the upper limit for tapered relief from £15,000 to £21,000.
The Arithmetic of Reform
Analysis from the global tax firm Ryan suggests these changes would exempt more than 140,000 small business premises from paying rates entirely. Yet, the math behind the proposal has invited skepticism. Alex Probyn, practice leader for property tax at Ryan, questioned whether the plan could truly be revenue neutral.
“Larger commercial properties are already contributing more through the existing business rates surtax to fund lower liabilities for retail, hospitality and leisure,” Probyn stated. “The obvious question is whether they are now going to be asked to contribute even more.”
A Fragile Sector Under Pressure
The push for reform arrives as the retail sector claws its way through a delicate recovery. Office for National Statistics data recorded an uptick in retail sales in May, buoyed by warmer weather and a surge in non-food spending. Still, the underlying sentiment remains grim.
The Confederation of British Industry (CBI) has labeled the current regime a “growth killer.” Their data shows that many firms have reduced or delayed investment specifically because of business rates. With the UK maintaining the highest property tax burden in the OECD relative to GDP—more than four times the level seen in Germany—the pressure to act is mounting.
The Tax on Ambition
Louise Hellem, chief economist at the CBI, warned that policymakers must avoid merely shuffling the burden between industries. “Business rates are no longer just a cost of doing business—they’re a major tax on ambition and one that effectively penalises investment,” Hellem said.
Retailers are currently squeezed by rising wage, energy, and operating costs. While the government recently introduced a 2.8p surtax on properties with rateable values exceeding £500,000 to fund existing relief, Burnham’s proposal marks a much deeper shift. Whether his strategy can survive the constraints of broader party policy, however, remains to be seen.
Keep reading