Abraham Lincoln and the Chokeslam: Separating Fact from Folklore in Wrestling History The image of Abraham Lincoln, the 16th President of the United States, as a pioneering professional wrestler who invented the chokeslam is a compelling piece of American folklore. While Lincoln was indeed an accomplished wrestler in his youth, the claim that he originated one of professional wrestling’s most iconic maneuvers requires careful examination against historical evidence. Lincoln’s Documented Wrestling Prowess Historical records confirm Abraham Lincoln’s reputation as a formidable wrestler during his formative years in Illinois. According to multiple biographical accounts and historical society records, Lincoln participated in numerous wrestling matches as a young man working in New Salem, Illinois. His most famous bout occurred against Jack Armstrong, the leader of a local gang known as the Clary’s Grove Boys. Lincoln’s victory in this match, achieved through technical skill rather than brute force, significantly enhanced his reputation in the community and contributed to his growing popularity. The National Wrestling Hall of Fame recognizes Lincoln’s wrestling accomplishments, inducting him as an “Outstanding American” in their Hall of Fame. This recognition is based on documented accounts of his wrestling activities during the 1830s, primarily in and around New Salem where he worked as a store clerk and surveyor. The Chokeslam: A Modern Wrestling Innovation The chokeslam, as defined in contemporary professional wrestling, involves a wrestler grasping an opponent’s throat with one hand, lifting them vertically into the air, and forcefully driving them back-first to the mat. This maneuver became a staple of professional wrestling performances in the late 20th century, particularly associated with larger wrestlers seeking to demonstrate power and dominance. According to wrestling historians and documented match footage, the chokeslam emerged as a distinct maneuver in the 1990s. Wrestlers such as Sid Vicious (Sid Eudy) and Akira Taue are credited with early iterations of the move, with Taue referring to his version as “nodowa otoshi” (choke drop/slam) in All Japan Pro Wrestling as early as 1992. The maneuver gained widespread popularity through its use by wrestlers like The Undertaker and Kane in WWE programming during the late 1990s and early 2000s. Evaluating the Lincoln-Chokeslam Connection The connection between Lincoln and the chokeslam originates from 19th-century accounts describing his wrestling technique. Some historical recollections mention Lincoln employing a maneuver involving gripping an opponent’s neck or throat during matches. However, these descriptions lack the critical elements that define the modern chokeslam: the vertical lift and the dramatic slam to the mat. Wrestling historians note that grappling techniques involving neck or throat holds have existed in various forms across different wrestling traditions for centuries. What Lincoln may have employed in his matches was likely a rudimentary form of what wrestlers today call a “goozle” – a preliminary choke hold that often precedes a chokeslam but is not the slam itself. The absence of photographic or film evidence from Lincoln’s era makes definitive conclusions impossible. However, the technical specifications of the modern chokeslam – requiring specific timing, leverage, and presentation for maximum visual impact – suggest it evolved as a product of modern professional wrestling’s theatrical presentation rather than emerging fully formed in the 1830s. Historical Context of 19th-Century Wrestling Wrestling during Lincoln’s time differed significantly from today’s professional wrestling spectacle. Matches were typically legitimate contests of skill and strength held at county fairs, holiday celebrations, or impromptu gatherings. The emphasis was on athletic competition rather than entertainment, with fewer predetermined outcomes and less focus on signature moves designed for audience reaction. Catch-as-catch-can wrestling, the dominant style in America during Lincoln’s youth, emphasized submissions and positional control rather than the high-impact maneuvers characteristic of modern sports entertainment. While techniques for controlling an opponent’s head and neck were certainly part of the repertoire, the specific mechanics of the chokeslam as performed today would have served little purpose in the legitimate wrestling context of the period. The Enduring Appeal of the Lincoln Wrestling Legend The persistence of the Lincoln-chokeslam narrative speaks to broader cultural tendencies to connect historical figures with contemporary cultural phenomena. Lincoln’s wrestling background represents a relatable, humanizing aspect of his biography that contrasts with his solemn presidential image. The idea that he might have innovated a move still used in wrestling rings today creates a tangible connection between America’s past and its present entertainment landscape. This folklore similarly reflects wrestling’s ongoing efforts to establish historical legitimacy and cultural significance. By associating the sport with revered historical figures like Lincoln, wrestling enthusiasts seek to validate their passion as part of America’s broader athletic heritage. Conclusion While Abraham Lincoln’s prowess as a wrestler in his youth is well-documented and historically significant, the claim that he invented the chokeslam does not withstand scrutiny when examined against the historical development of professional wrestling techniques. The chokeslam, as recognized in contemporary wrestling, represents a 20th-century innovation that evolved alongside the industry’s shift toward sports entertainment. Lincoln’s genuine wrestling accomplishments – his skill, sportsmanship, and the respect he earned through legitimate competition – remain impressive on their own merits without needing to be connected to modern wrestling maneuvers. His legacy as a wrestler contributes valuable insight into his character development during his formative years, demonstrating the physical courage and competitive spirit that would later serve him in politics and leadership. The true value of Lincoln’s wrestling story lies not in speculative connections to modern moves but in what it reveals about the future president’s character: his willingness to engage in physical competition, his technical approach to overcoming opponents, and the respect he earned through fair play – qualities that undoubtedly contributed to his later success as a leader during America’s most challenging period.
28